Yearly Archives: 2024

by -
0 730
Police car

After an extensive investigation, detectives from the Suffolk County SPCA arrested a Port Jefferson Station man on Sept. 13 for animal cruelty.On July 1 the Suffolk County SPCA received a complaint from a veterinarian in Brookhaven Town regarding a case of extreme neglect.

The complaint reported a fifteen-year-old female Pit Bull Terrier “Coca” was brought in extremely emaciated, unable to rise or walk. There were significant ulcerated wounds all over body, notably in her stomach and groin area. There was foul odor from her open ulcerations that covered her stomach and groin area. The paws were red with irritation, overgrown nails that’s curled into the paws creating painful, open oozing wounds. Fur was missing from a significant portion of Coca. Coca was humanely euthanized by the hospital due to the extreme pain as a result of her condition. The reporting veterinarian stated it was one of the worst neglect cases she had ever examined.

On July 6 at approximately 10 a.m. SPCA Detectives responded to the owner’s residence in Port Jefferson Station with the assistance of the Suffolk County Police Department’s 7th Precinct uniform patrol. Coca was exhumed by Detectives and forensic necropsy preformed by Cornell University Animal Health Diagnostic Center Pathologists in Ithaca, NY.

On September 13, 2024 SPCA Detectives arrested Juan Vargas, 66, of Port Jefferson Station. He was charged with misdemeanor Animal Cruelty. Vargas is scheduled to appear in Suffolk County First District Court in Central Islip on October 3.

Animal cruelty will not be tolerated in Suffolk County. If you witness any incident of animal cruelty or neglect in Suffolk County please contact the Suffolk County SPCA at 631-382-7722.

From left, Beetlejuice, Lydia, Delia

Welcome to the 33rd edition of Paw Prints, a monthly column for animal lovers dedicated to helping shelter pets find their furever home.

From left, Beetlejuice, Lydia, Delia

 

Meet Beetlejuice, Lydia and Delia

These sweet babies at the Smithtown Animal Shelter are just 5 months old and ready for their furever home. Curious and playful, they can’t wait to get out of their cage and explore the world. They are spayed/neutered and up to date on their vaccinations. The shelter has a surplus of adorable furballs waiting for their heroes. Come visit them today! 631-360-7575.

Gizmo

Meet Gizmo

Waiting patiently at the Brookhaven Animal Shelter, this little guy is Gizmo, a spirited 10-year-old with a heart full of zest and a personality that’s anything but old! Despite his years, Gizmo is brimming with energy and loves to take charge of bird and squirrel duty in the yard. When he’s not on patrol, you’ll find him happily curled up in your lap, basking in the sun, or enjoying a leisurely walk. 

Gizmo does have a few quirks—he prefers not to have his back end touched and might show a little attitude if it happens (just a hint of spice!). He also has a cherry eye, but don’t let that fool you; it doesn’t impact his vision one bit. Gizmo would thrive in a home with a low-key canine companion to share his golden years and would do best with children aged 12 and up. He is neutered, vaccinated, and heartworm negative. If you’re looking for a loving lap companion with a playful side, Gizmo is ready to bring joy and warmth to your home!

Please  fill out a Matchmaker Adoption Application at www.brookhavenny.gov/152/Animal-Shelter to arrange a meet and greet

Houston

Meet Houston

Filled with sage advice and words of wisdom, meet Houston, a thirteen-year-old Beagle mix at Little Shelter in Huntington. While part of the “Silver Sneakers” set, this distinguished gentleman routinely logs in more steps than his kennel mates, knowing that keeping active and engaged is the key to staying youthful. Looking towards the future with a positive attitude, he’s confident that he has much to contribute as your best friend and companion, in addition to being an expert commentator on the upcoming Puppy Bowl! 

If you have room on your couch and a good supply of snacks, stop by Little Shelter to meet Houston…he’s the one appropriately dressed in the Superman t-shirt!

“The dog’s tail wagged. It was his tail’s job; to synchronize all nearby moods to the measure of his joy. A metronome of happiness.” 631-368-8770, ext. 21

Gizzy

Meet Gizzy

Thriving on tenderness, appreciation, encouragement, and butt scratches, meet Gizzy, a ten year old Shih-tzu mix at Little Shelter in Huntington. An impartial judge of character, once you earn her trust you’ll find her to be warm, affectionate and good-hearted. A girly girl, she loves to dress the part and prance down the walking path (aka runway!) showing off her impeccable style. Despite being visually challenged, she’s fiercely independent, enjoying exploratory walks guided by her other senses and the sound of your voice. 

With a resilient spirit and the soul of a warrior, Gizzy has proven she can handle anything life throws her way. Now she’s ready for the challenging task of screening potential adopters to find her forever home, confident she’ll have her happily ever after. You’ll want to be first in line to meet this little force of nature…ask for Gizzy! 631-368-8770, ext. 21

Elvira
Spider

Meet Elvira and Spider

Kent Animal Shelter in Calverton has a bumper crop of kittens available for adoption including, from left, Elvira, a beautiful 6-month-old female, and Spider, a 4 1/2-month-old male. Come find your new best friend! 631-727-5731

TEACHER’S PET MONTH

Did you know? For the month of September, the Town of Brookhaven Animal Shelter, 300 Horseblock Road, Brookhaven offers a “Teacher’s Pet” special promotion — All animals that are ” School Age” (4 years old and up) are free. 631-451-695

Rescue is a lifestyle. Adopt, don’t shop.

Check out the next Paw Prints in the issue of October 17.

Paw Prints is generously sponsored by Mark T. Freeley, Esq.

 

From left, Oscar Rivera-Cruz from the University of Puerto Rico, BNL materials scientist Anibal Boscoboinik, Alexander Bailey from West Virginia State University, and Jeremy Lopez from the University of Puerto Rico. Photo courtesy of BNL

By Daniel Dunaief

It’s been a banner year for ideas and potential products that trap noble gases at Brookhaven National Laboratory. So-named for their full complement of electrons, noble gases tend to be less reactive than other atoms that can add electrons to their outer shells.

While their name sounds grandiose, these gases are anything but, particularly when people inhale the radioactive and prevalent gas radon, which can cause lung cancer or when the decay of uranium into xenon makes a nuclear reactor less efficient.

When he was studying how hydrocarbons react at the active site of zeolite models, Brookhaven National Laboratory’s material scientist Anibal Boscoboinik made an accidental discovery about a decade ago that some nanomaterials, which are incredibly small, trap these gases.

Among several other projects he’s working on, Boscoboinik has since studied these nanocages, learning about the trapping mechanism and making variations of these materials and trapping methods that can be useful for a wide range of applications. 

The Battelle Memorial Institute, which partners with Stony Brook University to form Brookhaven Science Associates and manages nine national labs across the country, named Boscoboinik an “inventor of the year” for his work developing these materials.

Battelle awards an inventor of the year to a researcher from each institution under its management, recognizing efforts that contribute to science or engineering and that can have a positive impact on society.

“It feels really good to be recognized for the work,” said Boscoboinik, who is proud of the many people who made this progress possible directly and indirectly. “It would be amazing if we get to see something that stemmed from an accidental discovery doing very basic fundamental research becoming a real-life application that can benefit society.”

At the same time, three students from minority serving institutions were selected to receive seed grants as a part of MSI (for Minority Serving Institutions) Connect at BNL, in which they seek to commercialize a way to remove radon from the air.

They may work in a business to business model to supply other companies that can incorporate their materials into products.

The students, Jeremy Lopez Flores and Oscar Rivera-Cruz from the University of Puerto Rico and Alexander Bailey from West Virginia State University, will enter phase 2 in the process. The next phase of funding comes from other sources, such as FedTech. Boscoboinik will advise the students as they develop the company and any potential products.

These undergraduate students are looking to remove radon from the air at a concentration of four picocuries per liter, which is equivalent to smoking eight cigarettes a day.

“I am certainly pleased that the value of our collective output was recognized,” said Bailey, who is from St. Albans, West Virginia, in an email. Bailey, a sophomore double majoring in chemistry and math, plans to attend graduate school after completing his undergraduate studies.

Rivera-Cruz, who is a senior majoring in Cellular and Molecular Biology, appreciated the guidance from Boscoboinik, whom he described in an email as an “incredible resource for the team” and suggested that the team was “extremely grateful and lucky” to have Boscoboinik’s support.

In other research

As a staff member at the Center for Functional Nanomaterials, Boscoboinik spends half his time working with scientists from around the world who come to the CFN to conduct experiments and half his time working on his own research.

The process of granting time to use the facilities at BNL is extremely competitive, which means the projects he works on with other scientists are compelling. “While I help them with their research, I get to learn from them,” he said.

Boscoboinik regularly works with the group of Professor Guangwen Zhou from Binghamton University. In recent work, they explored the dynamics of peroxide formation on a copper surface in different environments.

In his own work, Boscoboinik is also interested in trying to help the nuclear energy community.

During the breakdown of radioactive uranium, the process heats up water in a tank, moving a turbine that produces energy.

The breakdown of uranium, however, produces the noble gas xenon, which is a neutron absorber, making reactors less efficient.

Boscoboinik anticipates that any new product that could help the field of nuclear energy by removing xenon could be a decade or more away. “This is a highly regulated industry and changes in design take a very long time,” he explained.

Boscoboinik is also collaborating with researchers from Johns Hopkins University on metal organic frameworks. Some molecules pass through these frameworks more rapidly than others, which could enable researchers to use these frameworks to separate out a heterogeneous collection of molecules.

Additionally, he is developing processes to understand dynamic conditions that affect different types of reactions. At this point, he has been looking at the oxidation of carbon monoxide, which he called the “drosophila” of surface science for its widespread use and versatility, to develop the methodology. In oxidation, carbon monoxide mixes with oxygen to make carbon dioxide.

In his work, Boscoboinik has collaborated with Qin Wu, who deploys artificial intelligence to interpret the data he generates in his experiments.

The long-term plan is to develop complex-enough algorithms that suggest experiments based on the analysis and interpretation of data.

Outside the lab

Boscoboinik is a part of a collaborative effort to combine science and music. “We use music as a way to enable conversations between scientists and the general public” to help make the sometimes complex and jargon-laden world of science more accessible, he said.

In Argentina, research groups have taken famous musicians to the lab to perform concerts while encouraging conversations about science. During the course of their visits, the musicians speak with scientists for the benefit of the public. In prior seasons, the musicians used popular songs to relate to the research the scientists they interview do. Part of the plan is to make new songs related to the research.

Boscoboinik is part of a collaboration between Music for Science, the network of Argentinian scientists abroad, and the Argentinian diplomatic missions, including the embassies and the consulates. At some point in the future he may create a show that relates noble gases and music.

As with his some of his scientific work, the connection between music and research is a developing proof of concept that he hopes has broader appeal over time.

By Toni-Elena Gallo

Alan Blanco is doing his part to keep two East Setauket staples alive: The Butchers Market, previously Setauket Quality Meats, at 232 Main St., and Setauket Seafood at 230 Main St..

Both establishments have been in existence for over 40 years — the fish store, previously owned by Eddie Lin, and the meat shop and butcher, most recently owned by Brittany McClung.

“I worked at Savino’s Hideaway, near Cedar Beach in Mount Sinai, for many years, and I had a relationship [with Eddie] because the restaurant has bought fish from him for years. So, one day, he said he was selling and that no one was interested in buying,” Blanco said.

“And [he turned to me] and said, ‘Do you want to buy it?’”

Coincidentally, the butcher shop was also up for sale, and Blanco decided why not buy both.

When speaking about the businesses’ beloved status in East Setauket, Blanco added, “I love this neighborhood, and I know the community did not want to see these businesses go under. And, I thought maybe it was time for me to go [into business] for myself.”

Blanco has owned the fish store for about six months and acquired the butcher’s around two months ago.

He says that his main priority is staying true to the customer experience the community has been accustomed to for generations.

“We want to keep the stores’ reputations high. Eddie is still helping me out,” Blanco continued. 

“I want to keep the businesses’ legacies alive and provide good, quality produce.”

The primary change Blanco is bringing to these institutions is the incorporation of prep-prepared, which he said will make it easy for customers to “grab and go.”

Both the fish and meat stores will offer selections such as sausage and peppers, chicken francese, Italian-style meatballs, cooked fish and even vegetarian options such as eggplant parmesan.

While Blanco continues to apply his personal touches to the shops, he is just glad that the stores did not have to “disappear forever.”

“I am very excited to be here, and I’ve received such positive feedback from the community. More food options will be available in the near future,” he said.

by -
0 687
Have you seen Vianna?

Update: Vianna Dettling, who was reported missing on September 19, has been located and is unharmed.

Below is the original press release:

Suffolk County Police Fourth Squad detectives are seeking the public’s help to locate a Smithtown teen who was reported missing on Sept. 19.

Vianna Dettling was reported missing by a family member after she was last seen getting into a white sedan in front of 299 Lilac Lane, Smithtown, at approximately 3:10 a.m. Dettling, 18, of 256 Lilac Lane, is Caucasian, 5 feet 6 inches tall, 150 pounds with brown hair and blue eyes. She was last seen wearing a multicolored t-shirt and black pants.

Detectives are asking anyone with information on her location to call 911 or the Fourth Squad at 631- 854-8451.

By Bill Landon

It was a battle of the unbeaten between the Ward Melville Patriots and Bay Shore/Islip on Monday afternoon, Sept. 16, in a field hockey league matchup.

The Patriots pressured the Bay Shore defenders constantly with a 4-0 shutout over their visitors in the Division I contest. 

Ward Melville junior Hadley Torre found the back of the net twice, senior forward Peyton Phillips scored along with two assists and senior midfielder Jadyn Stoecker rocked the box. 

Bay Shore goalie Morgan Cousins had a busy day guarding the box with 18 saves, while Ward Melville’s keeper Olivia Zummo stopped two.

The win lifts the Patriots to the top of the Division I leaderboard.

— Photos by Bill Landon 

by -
0 443
Barbara R. Mohar. Courtesy Allison Mohar Fabella

Prepared by Allison Mohar Fabella

Barbara R. Mohar passed away on Aug. 20, in Marlborough, Massachusetts. She was a beloved piano teacher and college music professor, dedicating more than 40 years to teaching hundreds of students at her home in Stony Brook, and teaching music history at Long Island University.

Known for her creative spirit, generosity and tenacity, Mohar was a charismatic force who always found beauty in her surroundings and in the arts. Her love of painting, music, gardening and animals reflected her deep appreciation for all things beautiful. She cherished her piano students as if they were family, leaving a lasting impact through her dedication and generosity.

Mohar was featured in Newsday and The Village Times Herald for her imaginative teaching style, transforming her Stony Brook home into a theater for her annual “piano plays.” These productions brought music to life, casting each student as a character with costumes, dialogue and choreography.

In addition to her private teaching, Mohar was an adjunct music professor for over 30 years at Long Island University where she received the “Excellence in Teaching” award. She also served as program director for the Suffolk County Music Guild, was a music specialist for the Creative Learning Program of the Long Island Regional Advisory Council on Higher Education and was a board member of The Friends of Sunwood.

A lifelong painter, Mohar filled the walls of her sunroom with paintings of animals, landscapes and flowers, many inspired by her own garden.

Born in Youngstown, Ohio, Mohar studied at the Dana School of Music until she married and relocated to New York City with her musician husband, who was attending the Juilliard School of Music. She later earned both her bachelor’s and master’s degrees in music from C.W. Post College in Greenvale, graduating with highest honors.

Mohar is survived by her son Brian (Diane) of New Kingston; daughters Victoria (Imade Sudana) of Acton, Massachusetts and Allison Fabella (Ted) of Atlanta, Georgia; five grandchildren; three great-grandchildren and her ex-husband Conrad Mohar, with whom she remained close.

In addition to a private family service in Upstate New York in September, a casual gathering will be held on Friday, Sept. 20, from 7 to 10 p.m. at Eastern Pavilion Chinese restaurant in Setauket. Friends and students are welcome to share memories and raise a glass in her honor. In lieu of flowers, contributions in Mohar’s memory may be made to the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA), a cause dear to her.

Ducks walk alongside the storm-ravaged pond. Photo by Toni-Elena GalloPhoto by Toni-Elena Gallo

By Sabrina Artusa

At Mill Pond in Stony Brook, a group of swans and mallards can be observed on the sandy banks. On occasion, some Canadian geese can be seen as well, crossing the road confused and displaced. 

After August’s rain, Stony Brook’s residents — both people and animals — are gradually recouping. A month later, the road ahead is a little clearer as questions on funding and rebuilding become less intimidating. 

Community support

Gloria Rocchio, president of The Ward Melville Heritage Organization which owns the Grist Mill and Mill Pond, said she is grateful for the “unbelievable” amount of support the community has shown her organization, especially as she navigates the rebuilding process. 

Over 100 people came to cleanup sessions at the Mill Pond where they fished out personal effects that washed into the creek after a nearby house was damaged. 

People across the country have been touched by the disaster — Rocchio has received donations and letters from people nationwide. Some were former residents. 

Rebuilding

The resolve to rebuild exists in abundance. Governmental officials such as Suffolk County Executive Ed Romaine (R), Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) and community leaders like Rocchio have repeatedly announced their dedication to this area. 

“People sat on the boulders, watched the wildlife, watched the sunset — that’s what we want them to have again. We have to have it back,” Rocchio said. 

Rocchio said her organization has met with an engineer and has hired a marine expert to ensure the debris is cleaned out. Further, she said they are in the midst of designing a new plan for the creek leading to the pond. 

The 1699 grist mill was not severely damaged. Over a foot of water washed into the basement on the west side. Now, Rocchio is concerned with waterproofing and repairing the building in a way that prevents further damage. She is also worried that the wheel will suffer from lack of use without water to keep it turning. 

Town of Brookhaven officials have also stated their intentions to construct a dam that has the capacity to allow for larger amounts of water to pass through. The previous dam was not designed to endure such a large rush of water. 

Stony Brook University

Two of Stony Brook University’s residence halls were damaged after severe flooding, putting the buildings out of commission. The Mendelsohn buildings were flooded with 4-6 feet of water. 

 With limited housing, the university initiated a $5,000 incentive to students that cancels their housing plan. The university also added beds to rooms in other halls, making them triples instead of doubles and started placing returning students in nearby hotels. 

“We have expanded our recharge basins to handle increased demand. Last year, we installed a stormwater pump lift station specifically designed to redirect stormwater away from Gray and Ammann residence halls,” William Herrmann, vice president for Facilities & Services, wrote in an email. 

“We have also submitted grants to secure funding for additional mitigation efforts, including the installation of stormwater retention systems, bioswales and rain gardens in the most vulnerable areas of our campus,” he added.

Funding

It is uncertain if federal aid will be secured to fund the repairs to town infrastructure. In order to gain access to federal aid through the Federal Emergency Management Agency, damages must meet a $37.5 million threshold. 

Rocchio said WMHO needs funding for the grist mill. 

Homeowners have the option to apply for a grant with the New York State Housing Trust Fund Agency to be reimbursed for damage that wasn’t covered by insurance. Applicants could be given up to $50,000 depending on the county’s median income. Applications should be made through the Long Island Housing Partnership. The deadline to apply is Oct. 7, and grants are awarded until funds are exhausted. Please email LIHP at [email protected] before applying. 

Looking ahead

Stony Brook is moving forward, despite the unpleasant interruption the storm posed to summer affairs. 

Rocchio said that tourism and visitation to Stony Brook village is almost as it was before Aug. 18.

Avalon Nature Preserve has reopened and was relatively unharmed, although some trails needed maintenance.

After the storm, residents from across Suffolk County organized efforts to save the fish that were stranded in the diminishing pond. 

In another instance, a gas station owner, noticing a particularly weary looking Canadian goose wandering outside his gas station, provided food and water to the confused bird, who Rocchio guesses was born at the pond. The bird now hangs around the gas station regularly, even allowing his head to be pet. This owner muses that he adopted the goose, in a way.

“I do believe that when the Mill Pond is back with water that they will come back,” Rocchio said. 

It could be some time until Stony Brook Mill Pond and the Grist Mill return to their former state, but it is a comfort to know that Stony Brook remains alive and well, and that the vitality of the community, like the pond, still flows. 

Roasted Tomato and Bell Pepper Soup

By Heidi Sutton

If your garden is still spitting out tomatoes and peppers, try the following recipes for stuffed peppers for breakfast and tomato and bell pepper soup for lunch or dinner .

Stuffed Breakfast Peppers

Recipe courtesy of Amber Gray

Stuffed Breakfast Peppers

YIELD: Makes 4 servings

INGREDIENTS: 

2 large green bell peppers seeded, cut in half lengthwise

1 teaspoon olive oil

1/2 sweet onion diced

1/2 medium tomato seeded, chopped

3 slices bacon or breakfast sausage, cooked, chopped

1 cup chopped kale or spinach, tough stems removed

4 large eggs

2 tablespoons 1% milk

1/2 cup shredded low-fat mozzarella cheese

1/2 cup salsa or tomato sauce

DIRECTIONS:

Preheat oven to 350°F. Arrange pepper halves in 13×9-inch baking dish. Heat oil in skillet over medium heat; add onion and cook 3 minutes. Add tomatoes, bacon and kale or spinach, and cook 2-3 minutes. Spoon vegetables into pepper halves. Whisk eggs and milk in small bowl until well blended. Pour evenly over vegetable mixture in pepper halves. Bake 25-30 minutes. Remove from oven, top peppers with cheese and return to oven. Bake 5 minutes, or until cheese is melted. Top each pepper with 2 tablespoons salsa or tomato sauce.

Roasted Tomato and Bell Pepper Soup

Recipe courtesy of Tracy Shaw

Roasted Tomato and Bell Pepper Soup

YIELD: Makes 4 servings

INGREDIENTS: 

4 bell peppers

2 lbs tomatoes cherry or other

5 garlic cloves

1 yellow onion – peeled and cut in half

2 cups low sodium chicken broth or vegetable broth

Salt and pepper to taste

DIRECTIONS:

Preheat oven to 400 degrees F. Cut the bell peppers in half and clean out the seeds and membrane. Spray baking sheets with olive oil. Place the pepper halves, tomatoes, onion, and garlic cloves on prepared baking sheets. Roast for 20-30 minutes, until the skin is dark on the peppers and have collapsed. The skin on the tomatoes will soften and begin to burst. Allow the peppers to cool and remove the skin. Place all the vegetables and the juices from the tomato pan into a stock pot or dutch oven. Add in the chicken broth, salt and pepper. Using an immersion blender, blend until smooth. *If you don’t have an immersion blender, use a regular blender. Heat and serve.

Ward Melville High School. File photo by Greg Catalano
Additional transportation costs would come from within the budget

By Mallie Jane Kim

Will Three Village secondary students get 35 minutes more sleep?

Most parents who showed up to comment publicly at school district-sponsored forums Sept. 10 and 17 believe they should.

“This is basic biology,” said one parent, who identified herself as a neurologist and pointed to scientific studies on adolescent sleep needs. She said allowing teens to sleep later impacts more than academics and test scores. “Mental health improves, physical health improves, there are less motor vehicle accidents from those seniors,” she said. “It really seems like a very small price to pay for all of those advantages.”

The school board is considering a proposal to shift Ward Melville High School’s start time to 7:40 a.m., from 7:05, and push the junior high schools back from 7:40 a.m. to 8:15. Under the plan, Minnesauke Elementary School would join the three schools that start at 9:25 a.m., and Nassakeag would stay at 8:40. 

The district is gathering feedback from all residents and employees through an online form to inform the school board’s decision. Each household in the district was sent a flier with a QR link to the form.

The proposed schedule requires nine additional buses and will add an estimated $1.4 million to the transportation budget, based on the district’s 2024-25 contract with the bus company, which is subject to change. Those funds, however, will have to come from within the existing overall budget, which for this school year is $236 million. Superintendent of Schools Kevin Scanlon has made it clear there is no will within the district to go above the state-mandated limits on increasing taxes year over year.

“We don’t have an unlimited pot of money,” Scanlon said. “We do not want to exceed the tax cap for any of these issues.”

The superintendent noted that the district has already been working to tighten its belt anywhere possible, including a $770,000 savings from restructuring the administration and about $3 million from retirements last year.

At the forums, some parents pointed out that in the context of a $236 million budget, $1.4 million amounts to about half a percent.

“I can’t think of anything we could do that is this easy for a million dollars that could benefit the kids this much,” commented one parent on Sept. 17.

District officials have publicly acknowledged they believe early school start times are a major problem for adolescents but have pointed to issues of transportation logistics and related costs in delaying a change.

Scanlon, who mentioned about 10% of high school students chronically miss first period, presented a detailed background of efforts to make secondary school start times later, as well as the rationale for trying to do so. 

“The issue for us is the way the schools are structured,” Scanlon explained, referring to the staggered school start times that allow the district to use far fewer buses than if all the schools started around the same time. “This is saving us money — if we change back to a different configuration, it’s going to cost us money.”

The current setup started in 2011, after the district adjusted start times to use fewer buses. For that effort, Three Village received a management efficiency grant from New York State paid out over three years and totaling $747,789, according to the district. 

But some commenters said these early start times highlighted an equity issue within the district: Certain parents have the ability to drive their students to school in the morning, which isn’t possible for those who have to be at work early or do not have anyone to stay home with younger sleeping children. 

“What we’re saying is the kids who have advantages — whether that be financial or their parents’ time — can sleep an extra half hour or 45 minutes and do better in school,” one woman argued. “And their mental health is more important than those kids who don’t have those advantages. That’s really troubling.”

Not all public commenters were against the early start times. 

“I thought it was disciplined,” said a woman who identified herself as Karen and said she had two Three Village graduates and current student. She added that her son couldn’t compete as a track athlete because he was up too late at night, studying. 

“If we had moved that start time up later, he would have stayed up even later,” she said. “I know in my household, it would not work.”

Others on social media and at the forums raised concerns about future transportation costs soaring due to the New York State mandate to electrify bus fleets in coming years, something Scanlon emphasized was out of the district’s control and an “unfunded mandate.”

Scanlon indicated that, as of the Sept. 17 meeting, about 200 people had participated in the online survey, and so far the opinions were varied. He encouraged every stakeholder to participate and let the school board hear their feedback.

“They read everything,” Scanlon assured audience members. “They will read every comment made by every community member, good, bad and indifferent.”

The online feedback form will be open until Sept. 30, and the board of education plans to discuss the issue in October.