The Three Village Historical Society presented its 24th Spirits Cemetery Tour, titled The Fickle Finger of Fate, Oct. 20.
Approximately 20 attendees at a time were led on walks through the Setauket Presbyterian and Caroline Church cemeteries as actors portrayed former Setauket and Stony Brook residents, some of whom knocked on death’s door too soon.
Ticket holders learned about William Sidney Mount and his interest in seances; the sickly Mary Swift Jones who accompanied her husband on a voyage to China where he brought a coffin on board in preparation of her death; Adelaide Sells, a gospel singer who won Amateur Night at Harlem’s Apollo Theatre; Alice Parsons who went missing in Stony Brook in 1939 and more.
1 of 15

Michael Tessler as George Dominick, a businessman and farmer from the 1800s. Photo from the Three Village Historical Society

Donna Smith as Alice Parsons who went missing in Stony Brook in 1939. Photo from the Three Village Historical Society

Bonnie Duvall as Adelaide Sells, the gospel singer and back-up singer for Johnny Ace. Photo from the Three Village Historical Society

Sahil Sangwan as William Sidney Mount, the famed local artist known for his genre paintings. Photo by Rita J. Egan

Frank Turano as Henry Hackett Satterly who was buried in Mexico in 1846. A memorial to the Mexican War soldier stands in Setauket Presbyterian Church's cemetery. Photo by Rita J. Egan

Tara Ebrahimian as the sickly Mary Swift Jones who traveled on a voyage to China with her husband. Her husband was prepared for her death with a coffin on board. Photo by Dorri Auerbach

Steve Healy as the Roaming Detective asked guests if they knew who killed Alice Parsons who went missing in Stony Brook in 1939. Photo by Dorri Auerbach